
“There is an Anglican hymn that begins: “Once to every man and nation comes the moment to decide, In the strife of truth with falsehood, for the good or evil side.”
I’ve reached that moment about Gaza. I can no longer remain silent about – or try to justify – the actions of the Israeli government and armed forces in Gaza and the West Bank. I have decided: their actions are evil. I can only hope that this nation – my nation – like so many others soon comes to the same decision. The moment to decide is overdue.
Every statement I make here is made in full awareness of the horror inflicted on the people of Israel on Oct. 7. We should never forget the blatant, willful cruelty that Hamas unleashed that day, or their tearing away innocent civilians to serve as hostages. In intent and execution, it was pure evil. The Hamas perpetrators should be found and brought to justice for their crimes.
So too should the West Bank vigilantes and Israeli officials who’ve now killed nearly as many West Bank Palestinians as Hamas killed Israelis on Oct. 7, according to the reports from the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs.
Now to Gaza. For each of the 1,200 Israelis butchered by Hamas, the IDF has murdered more than 50 Palestinians, many of them women and children. Fifty eyes for an eye. Netanyahu and the IDF have killed one out of thirty-five Gazans so far and wounded many more. This is not unfortunate “collateral damage”; it is a war crime. The perpetrators should be found and brought to justice for their crimes.
The deliberate bombing of hospitals, schools, and universities in Gaza is just as clear a war crime as it is in Kyiv or Kharkiv. Such bombings are sometimes justified by the claim that “it was an accident” or “the hospital was a Hamas command center.” Nonsense. How many “accidents” add up to a deliberate policy? How many “command centers” does Hamas need?
Starving a civilian population is also a war crime. Who can watch starving kids waving their pans and buckets, hoping for a ladle-full of soup without pity and revulsion? These kids are desperate for soup – not bread or meat or fresh vegetables, just soup. Soup to stay alive. Meanwhile, thousands of truckloads of food and medicines sit just outside Gaza, kept out by the Israeli authorities. These same authorities claim they’d allow the food in if only the paperwork were right or if the distribution of food were better managed or if Hamas didn’t get its hands on any of it. Who cares about paperwork or even some Hamas guy eating better if kids are starving? Using hunger as a weapon is evil. The perpetrators should be found and brought to justice for their crimes.
Some readers may point out that I am accepting Gazan or U.N. figures and information – isn’t that biased? To which I respond: “So I should trust news from the other party in the fight? From Netanyahu, who claims ‘there is no starvation in Gaza’?” To get accurate, unbiased information, you would need observers and reporters on the ground. The IDF either won’t let them into Gaza, or kills them.
I come from a military family: my father, grandfather, and great-grandfather were all soldiers. That background allows me to question the military effectiveness of IDF operations in Gaza. Why has it taken the most potent military force in the Middle East 20 months to (partially) neutralize a few thousand Hamas fighters? It is certainly not because the IDF is operating with kid gloves. Instead, it is operating ineffectively. To find and neutralize Hamas tunnels, you need troops on the ground. Bombing or shelling buildings that may be above the tunnels is ineffective. To kill Hamas fighters, you need troops on the ground to find them. Indiscriminate bombing is ineffective and has killed far more civilians than Hamas fighters.
The most charitable interpretation of this ineffectiveness is that the IDF will go to any lengths to minimize Israeli military casualties, though I wonder if Israeli casualties would have been fewer had the IDF relied more on soldiers and less on bombs at the outset. I suspect, however, that the ineffectiveness is purposeful, knowingly designed to prolong the war and increase the suffering of the people of Gaza. A continuing war benefits Netanyahu and his colleagues.
For all these reasons, I came to the moment to decide: the government of Israel is on the evil side. Is this judgment anti-Semitic? If you think so, you must think the same of many millions of people the world over, including a great many Israelis and many Jews in the U.S. My criticism is aimed not at a religion or a people or a country, but at Netanyahu and his government. It is no more antisemitic to criticize Netanyahu and his policies than it is anti-British to point out the folly of Brexit or anti-American to criticize Trump’s handling of immigration.
As I have said above, I hope America soon decides the way I did. If it does, there are actions America can take. Our government could demand an immediate cease-fire, with harsh penalties for either side that breaks it, including the immediate cessation of all military aid to Israel. We could demand the immediate release of all the Israeli hostages and an immediate stop to the harassment of West Bank Palestinians. We could support international courts in their pursuit of war criminals on both sides. We could use air and naval assets to deliver food and medicines directly to Gaza – immediately. We could reaffirm in no uncertain terms our absolute commitment to the continued existence of the state of Israel. We could assert in equally certain terms our support for an independent state of Palestine. We could pledge a dollar for the reconstruction of a Palestinian Gaza for each dollar we send to Israel. We could do all of these things, if only we decide.
“Once to every nation comes the moment to decide, for the good or evil side…” That moment is here.
The Tribune is committed to publishing a diversity of opinions. We’d like to hear from you. Send your articles to our email: opinion@merotribune.com.
Follow the Mero Tribune on Facebook and Twitter.


